Surprisingly, I’m not talking about the anime (which I hear is even worse), but the manga.
Now, although Bakuman operates on an interesting premises (a manga about writing manga, what can go wrong?), it’s the characters that I’ve absolutely grown to despise. After chapter 63 (partly into volume 8), I couldn’t stand them, and ragequit.
But let me explain; it’s not that I hate all the characters, it’s that I hate all the female characters. I’ll just list all the females that come to mind, along with why they are so damned awful:
Aoki Yuriko – Ohgodwtf, this woman is simply so terrible. I haven’t seen a single scene where she’s depicted as an actual human being with human emotions (pity for a man who’s literally dying in a snowstorm doesn’t count; she left him to suffer for days in freezing weather, after all). On top of that, she apparently has no morals or humility; she never negotiates with anyone, leads people on only to screw them over, and copypastes ideas (taken from private conversations about personal lives) to manga. To put this in perspective, Makoto from School Days didn’t make me as angry as this woman.
Azuki Miho – While I had pegged her as simply weird for the whole “let’s not even see each other until we’re married” (there is nobody that would realistically go for that) thing, I realized that I hated her too after reading chapter 61 (or 62, I can’t be bothered to check). I absolutely cannot understand why hiding something you did wrong is totally fine, while your [partner? fiancĂ©?] doing the same is abhorrent.
While I’m at it, I’m just going to point out that if you can’t sing for your life, aren’t willing to become an idol or do anything remotely gravure, and only have looks to your name, you might as well stop trying to be a seiyuu and go to university.
Azuki Miyuki – I don’t quite think I hate her, but only because she doesn’t have many appearances. I’ll skip over this.
Iwase Aiko – Again, don’t really hate her, mostly because I’ve forgotten her as a character. However, from her meeting with Aoki in chapter [60? 61?], she seems horribly arrogant (“yes, I’ve completely reformed; I can now see manga as something with at least entertainment value“), which I suppose I can’t stand.
Kato Natsumi – No real comment; she doesn’t have many appearances. That said, she’s practically oblivious to Nakai’s advances, and that’s just awful.
Miyoshi Kaya – There’s a bit of hate for her; not because of her as a character, but for the mangaka’s inability to understand anything about females. It seemed obvious by the time I dropped this that Ohba Tsugumi (whoever that actually is) has completely given up on any realistic representation of girls, and resorted to using them as tools to make the manga slightly less male-dominated. Back to my original point; it’s not that Kaya is awful, it’s that she’s one-dimensional. Although “stupid tomboy” is an acceptable character (Aisaka Taiga from Toradora! pulled it off reasonably well), if the character has no personality to speak of, any appearances they’re given might as well be worthless.
Actually, while I’m complaining about how the story writer is a misogynist, I might as well go over other characters that strike me as terrible:
Hiramaru Kazuya – Lazy bastard who I fear more than I hate. As in “I’m afraid to become this guy in ten or twenty years”.
Koogy – Deluded narcissist. I understand that he’s supposed to be what passes for a “villain character” in this kind of manga, but that doesn’t keep me from hating him.
Ishizawa Hidemitsu – Same as Koogy, but a bigger asshole.
In short, this manga is awful because of the characters. If the characters were replaced with ones that weren’t so [makes me want to rage]-able, this would be a decent story. As it is, I can’t stand to read any more of it.
In the event that I don’t post something by the 31st, Happy New Year’s.